CNN Censors “Rude Giant”

Jeff Jarvis may well be right about political conventions these days being nothing more than contemptible “staged events to get media coverage” and therefore not worthy of reporting on, but they’re tailor made for the quirky news stylings of CNN’s veteran correspondent Jeanne Moos, whose “beat” is the offbeat, so to speak.

In today’s “Moost Unusual” bit, she zeroed in on a giant pizza cut into a wheat field near the Denver airport for Papa John’s that delegates (and the 15,000 reporters as well, presumably) to the Democratic National Convention will see as their aircraft are landing. To pad out the piece, Moos did a quick review of other giant “crop circle” advertisements as well as assorted giant figures cut into farm fields across the country and around the world.

Which brings us to the so-called “Rude Giant” (also known as the Cerne Abbas giant or, more simply, the “rude man”), a chalk figure carved into a hillside in Dorset, England that dates back to the late 17th century, although its precise origins are unknown. Some historians have speculated that it may have been a parody of Oliver Cromwell, the regicidal English dictator. Cromwell was, of course, a fanatical Puritan and if he was aware of the Cerne Abbas, doubtless would have found its giant phallus highly offensive.

The puritan spirit lives on at CNN apparently. For whatever reason, the network felt obliged to censor the Rude Giant’s “naughty bits” by pixelating them when they appeared in the Moos piece. The reason was probably less to prevent their viewers’ delicate eyes from being offended, than to avoid bothersome complaints about broadcasting something “obscene or indecent” in violation of the FCC regulations, but in either case, it seemed quite strange for a “news” network in the 21st century to apply that standard of prudery to a four hundred year chalk carving. For a country that treasures “free speech” and holds up the first amendment right as being almost sacrosanct, the daft constraints imposed by the archaic FCC regulations on broadcasters utilizing the public airwaves seem like a terrible contradiction to the right of free speech in this day and age.

About these ads

6 Comments

Filed under Free Speech, Media

6 responses to “CNN Censors “Rude Giant”

  1. Ti-Guy

    It’s interesting how Canadian and US approaches to freedom of expression establishes what is acceptable in both imagery and text/speech in the public forum. Sex and swearing in Canada is generally tolerated; violence and hate generally not. In the US, it’s the reverse.

  2. That is a curious paradox, isn’t it?

  3. Ti-Guy

    Speaking of unacceptable, I came across this and this yesterday.

    I’m going to roast in Hell for it, but I’m saving those links for future reference.

  4. Brilliant. I liked that crack about spending the £3 million on giving every Scotsman a shovel so they could dig a hole so deep that they could hand her over personally to Satan. :)

  5. Ti-Guy

    Yeah, that was hilarious.

    I liked the little children in the video singing “Ding, dong, the witch is dead.”

    Imagine how our free speech warriors would react to that kind of expression if it were common in our media? I just bet they’d be incoherent.

  6. Just wait until lyin’ Brian enters decrepitude and similar sentiments are revived… ;)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s